Fractals/Iterations in the complex plane/demm

This algorithm has 2 versions :

  • exterior
  • interior

Compare it with version for dynamic plane and Julia set : DEM/J

Exterior DEM/MEdit

Exterior DEM/M
simple boundary with DEM/M
Boundary with DEM/M and Sobel filter

Distance Estimation Method for Mandelbrots set ( DEM/M ) estimates distance from point   ( in the exterior of Mandelbrot set ) to nearest point in Mandelbrot set.[1][2]

It can be used to create B&W images from BOF :[3]

  • map 41 on page 84
  • map 43 on page 85
  • an unnumbered plot on page 188

Math formuleEdit

Math formula :[4][5][6]


where :


is a first derivative of   with respect to c which can be found by iteration starting with


and then replacing at every consecutive step


Escape radiusEdit

  • "you need to change "If mag > 2" to increase the escape radius. Attached is a comparison, showing that the "straps" reduce when the radius is increased, no harm going huge like R = 1e6 or so because once it escapes 2 it grows very fast. The bigger the radius, the more accurate the distance estimate." Claude [7]
  • Basically in testing magnitude squared against bailout
    • if your bailout is 10^4 then your DE estimates are accurate to 2 decimal figures i.e. if your DE is 0.01 then it's only accurate to +/-0.0001,
    • if your bailout is 10^6 then your DE estimates are accurate to 3 decimal figures (David Makin in


  • The Beauty of Fractals
  • The Science of Fractal Images, page 198,
  • Distance Estimator by Robert P. Munafo[8]

Pseuidocode by Claude Heiland-Allen[9]

foreach pixel c
  while not escaped and iteration limit not reached
    dz := 2 * z * dz + 1
    z := z^2 + c
  de := 2 * |z| * log(|z|) / |dz|
  d := de / pixel_spacing

Analysis of code from BOFEdit

"The Beauty of Fractals" gives an almost correct computer program for the distance estimation shown in the right image. A possible reason that that method did not gain ground is that the procedure in this program is seriously flawed: The calculation of   is performed (and completed) before the calculation of  , and not after as it ought to be (  uses  , not  ). For the successive calculation of  , we must know   (which in this case is 2 ). In order to avoid the calculation of   (k = 0, 1, 2, ...) again, this sequence is saved in an array. Using this array,   is calculated up to the last iteration number, and it is stated that overflow can occur. If overflow occurs the point is regarded as belonging to the boundary (the bail-out condition). If overflow does not occur, the calculation of the distance can be performed. Apart from it being untrue that overflow can occur, the method makes use of an unnecessary storing and repetition of the iteration, making it unnecessarily slower and less attractive. The following remark in the book is nor inviting either: "It turns out that the images depend very sensitively on the various choices" (bail-out radius, maximum iteration number, overflow, thickness of the boundary and blow-up factor). Is it this nonsense that has got people to lose all desire for using and generalizing the method? " Gertbuschmann

So :

  • in the loop, derivative should be calculated before the new z

"I'm finally generating DEM (Distance Estimate Method) based images that I'm happy with. It turns out that my code had a couple of bugs in it. The new code runs reasonably fast, even with all the extra math to compute distance estimates.

The algorithm in S of F I ("The Science of Fractal Images" uses a sharp cut-off from white to black when pixels get close enough to the set, but I find this makes for jagged looking plots. I've implemented a non-linear color gradient that works pretty well.

For pixels where their DE value is threshold>=DE>=0, I scale the value of DE to 1>=DE>=0, then do the calculation: gradient_value = 1 - (1-DE)^n, ("^n" means to the n power. I wish I could use superscripts!)

"n" is an adjustment factor that lets me change the shape of the gradient curve. The value "gradient_value" determines the color of the pixel. If it's 0, the pixel is colored at the starting color (white, for a B&W plot.) If "gradient_value" is 1, the pixel gets the end color (e.g.

black) For values of n>1, this gives a rapid change in color for pixels that are far from the set, and a slower change in value as DE approaches 0. For values of n<1, it gives a slow color change for pixels far from the set, and rapid change close to the set. For n=1, I get a linear

color gradient. The non-linear gradient lets me use the DE value to anti-alias my plots. By adjusting my threshold value and my adjustment value, I can get good looking results for a variety of images." Duncan C [10]

"All our DE formulas above are only approximations – valid in the limit n→∞, and some also only for point close to the fractal boundary. This becomes very apparent when you start rendering these structures – you will often encounter noise and artifacts.

Multiplying the DE estimates by a number smaller than 1, may be used to reduce noise (this is the Fudge Factor in Fragmentarium).

Another common approach is to oversample – or render images at large sizes and downscale." Mikael Hvidtfeldt Christensen [11]

Example codeEdit

Two algorithm in two loopsEdit

Here is Java function. It computes in one loop both : iteration   and derivative  . If (on dynamic plane) critical point :

  • does not escapes to infinity ( bailouts), then it belongs to interior of Mandelbrot set and has colour maxColor,
  • escapes then it maybe in exterior or near boundary. Its colour is "proportional" to distance between the point c and the nearest point in the Mandelbrot set. It uses also colour cycling ( (int)R % maxColor ).
// Java function by Evgeny Demidov from
// based on code by Robert P. Munafo from
  public int iterate(double cr, double ci, double K, double f) {
    double Cr,Ci, I=0, R=0,  I2=I*I, R2=R*R, Dr=0,Di=0,D;   int n=0;
    if (f == 0){ Cr = cr; Ci = ci;}
    else{ Cr = ci; Ci = cr;}
    do  {
      D = 2*(R*Dr - I*Di) +1;  Di = 2*(R*Di + I*Dr);  Dr = D;
      I=(R+R)*I+Ci;  R=R2-I2+Cr;  R2=R*R;  I2=I*I;  n++;
    } while ((R2+I2 < 100.) && (n < MaxIt) );
    if (n == MaxIt) return maxColor; // interior
    else{ // boundary and exterior 
     R = -K*Math.log(Math.log(R2+I2)*Math.sqrt((R2+I2)/(Dr*Dr+Di*Di))); // compute distance
     if (R < 0) R=0;
     return (int)R % maxColor; }; 

Here is cpp function. It gives integer index of color as an output.

 this function is  from program mandel ver 5.10 by Wolf Jung
 see file mndlbrot.cpp
It is checked first (in pixcolor)
that the point escapes before calling this function.  
So we do not compute the derivative and the logarithm 
when it is not escaping.  
This would not be a good idea if most points escape anyway.

int mndlbrot::dist(double a, double b, double x, double y)
{  uint j; 
   double xp = 1, yp = 0; // zp = xp+yp*i =  1 ; derivative 
   double nz, nzp; 
  // iteration 
  for (j = 1; j <= maxiter; j++)
   {  // zp
      nz = 2*(x*xp - y*yp); 
      yp = 2*(x*yp + y*xp); 
      xp = nz; //zp = 2*z*zp; on the dynamic plane 
      // if sign is positive it is parameter plane, if negative it is dynamic plane.
      if (sign > 0) xp++; //zp = 2*z*zp + 1 ; on the parameter plane
      //z = z*z + c; 
      nz = x*x - y*y + a; 
      y = 2*x*y + b; 
      x = nz; 
      nz = x*x + y*y; 
      nzp = xp*xp + yp*yp;
      // 2 conditions for stopping the iterations
      if (nzp > 1e40 || nz > bailout) break;

   // 5 types of points but 3 colors  
   /*  not escaping, rare 
       Is it not simply interior ???
       This should not be necessary.  I do not know why I included it,
       because in this case  pixcolor should not call dist.  If you do not
       have pixcolor before,  you should return 0 here. */
   if (nz < bailout) return 1; // not escaping, rare
   /*  If The Julia set is disconnected and the orbit of z comes close to
    z = 0 before escaping,  nzp will be small  */
   if (nzp < nz) return 10; // includes escaping through 0
   // compute estimated distance  = x 
   x = log(nz); 
   x = x*x*nz / (temp[1]*nzp); //4*square of dist/pixelwidth
   if (x < 0.04) return 1; // exterior but very close to the boundary
   if (x < 0.24) return 9; // exterior but close to the boundary
   return 10; //exterior : escaping and not close to the boundary
} //dist

Two algorithms in one loopEdit

  • distance rendering for fractals by ińigo quilez in c++[12]
Function GiveDistance(xy2,eDx,eDy:extended):extended;



Function PointIsInCardioid (Cx,Cy:extended):boolean;
 //Hugh Allen
  var DeltaX,DeltaY:extended;

     // cardioid checkig - thx to Hugh Allen
     //sprawdzamy Czy punkt  C jest w głównej kardioidzie
     //Cardioid in squere :[-0.75,0.4] x [ -0.65,0.65]
     if InRange(Cx,-0.75,0.4)and InRange(Cy,-0.65,065) then
        // M1= all C for which Fc(z) has  attractive( = stable) fixed point
        // znajdyjemy punkt staly z: z=z*z+c
        // czyli rozwiazujemy rownanie kwadratowe
        // zmiennej zespolonej o wspolczynnikach zespolonych
        // Z*Z - Z + C = 0
        //Delta:=1-4*a*c; Delta i C sa liczbami zespolonymi
        // Pierwiastek zespolony z delty
        // obliczmy punkt staly jeden z dwóch, ten jest prawdopodobnie przycišgajšcy
        ZFixedX:=1.0-PDeltyX; //0.5-0.5*PDeltyX;
        ZFixedY:=PDeltyY; //-0.5*PDeltyY;
        // jesli punkt stały jest przycišgajšcy
        // to należy do M1
        If (ZfixedX*ZFixedX + ZFixedY*ZFixedY)<1.0
          then result:=true;

          // ominięcie iteracji M1 przyspiesza 3500 do 1500 msek
        end; // if InRange(Cx ...

Function PointIsInComponent (Cx,Cy:extended):boolean;
//Hugh Allen

  var Dx:extended;
    // czy punkt C nalezy do koła na lewo od kardioidy
    // circle: center = -1.0  and radius 1/4
    if (Dx*Dx+Cy*Cy) < 0.0625
      then result:=true;


Procedure DrawDEM_DazibaoTrueColor; 
// draws Mandelbrot set in black and its complement in true color
// see
// by  Evgeny Demidov
// see also
// translation ( with modification) of Q-Basic program:
// see also my page

var iter:integer;
     eCy ,eCx:extended; // C:=eCx + eCy*i
     eX,eY:extended;    // Zn:=eX+eY*i
     eX2,eY2:extended;  //x2:=eX*eX;  y2:=eY*eY;
     eXY2:extended;  //  xy2:=x2+y2;
     eDx,eDy:extended; // derivative

  //compute bitmap
  for iY:= iYmin to iYMax do
      for iX:= iXmin to iXmax do
          If not PointIsInCardioid (eCx,eCy) and not PointIsInComponent(eCx,eCy)
                //  Z0:=0+0*i
                // iteration of Z ; Z= Z*z +c
                while ((iter<IterationMax) and (eXY2<=BailOut2)) do
                    eTempY:=2*eX*eY + eCy;
                    eTempX:=eX2-eY2 + eCx;
                  end; // while

                // drawing procedure
                if (iter<IterationMax)
                    distance:= GiveDistance(eXY2,eDx,eDy);
                    color:=Rainbow(1,500,Abs(Round(100*Log10(distance)) mod 500));
                    with Bitmap1.FirstLine[iY*Bitmap1.LineLength+iX] do
                          B := GetBValue(color);
                          G := GetGValue(color);
                          R := GetRValue(color);
                          //A := 0;
                        end; // with FirstLine[Y*LineLength+X]

                end // if (iter<IterationMax) then
              else  with Bitmap1.FirstLine[iY*Bitmap1.LineLength+iX] do
                          B := 0;
                          G := 0;
                          R := 0;
                          //A := 0;
             //--- end of drawing procedure ---
            end //  If not PointIsInCardioid ... then
          else with Bitmap1.FirstLine[iY*Bitmap1.LineLength+iX] do
                          B := 0;
                          G := 0;
                          R := 0;
                          //A := 0;
         //--- If not PointIsInCardioid ...
        end; // for iX
      end; // for iY


Modifications / optimisationsEdit

Creating DEM images can be improved by use of :


  • B of F map 43 DEM by Duncan Champney[16]
  • This plot is centered on -0.7436636773584340, 0.1318632143960234i at a width of about 6.25E-11
  • Smily Kaleidoscope by Duncan Champney [17]

Interior distance estimationEdit

Estimates distance from limitly periodic point   ( in the interior of Mandelbrot set ) to the boundary of Mandelbrot set.

Descriptions :[18]

Pixels colored according to the estimated interior distance

Math descriptionEdit

The estimate is given by :



  is the period = length of the periodic orbit

  is the point from parameter plane to be estimated

  is the complex quadratic polynomial  

  is the  -fold iteration of  

  is any of the   points that make the periodic orbit ( limit cycle )  

4 derivatives of   evaluated at   :





First partial derivative with respect to zEdit

It must be computed recursively by applying the chain rule :

Starting points :  

First iteration :  

Second iteration :  

General rule for p iteration :  

First partial derivative with respect to cEdit

It must be computed recursively by applying the chain rule :

Starting points :  

First iteration :  

Second iteration :  

General rule for p iteration :  

Second order partial derivative with respect to zEdit

It must be computed :

  • together with :  and  
  • recursively by applying the chain rule

Starting points :  

First iteration :  

Second iteration :  

General rule for p iteration :  

Second order mixed partial derivativeEdit




  • choose c
  • check if critical point for given c is periodic ( interior ) or not ( exterior or near boundary or to big period )
    • if not periodic do not use this algorithm ( use exterior version)
    • if periodic compute period and periodic point  
  • using   compute distance using p iteration

Computing period and periodic pointEdit

Computing distanceEdit


  • Java code by Albert Lobo Cusidó[19]
  • Haskell code by Claude[20] and image [21]
  • processing code[22] and description[23] by tit_toinou


There are two practical problems with the interior distance estimate:

  • first, we need to find   precisely,
  • second, we need to find   precisely.

The problem with   is that the convergence to   by iterating   requires, theoretically, an infinite number of operations.

The problem with period is that, sometimes, due to rounding errors, a period is falsely identified to be an integer multiple of the real period (e.g., a period of 86 is detected, while the real period is only 43=86/2). In such case, the distance is overestimated, i.e., the reported radius could contain points outside the Mandelbrot set.



  • Milnor "Self-similarity and hairiness in the Mandelbrot set" in Computers in Geometry and Topology, 1989.
  1. A Cheritat wiki-draw: Mandelbrot_set
  2. fractalforums : m-set-distance-estimation
  3. fractalforums discussion : How are B&W images from "Beauty of Fractals" created?
  4. Milnor (in Dynamics in One Complex Variable, appendix G)
  5. Heinz-Otto Peitgen (Editor, Contributor), Dietmar Saupe (Editor, Contributor), Yuval Fisher (Contributor), Michael McGuire (Contributor), Richard F. Voss (Contributor), Michael F. Barnsley (Contributor), Robert L. Devaney (Contributor), Benoit B. Mandelbrot (Contributor) : The Science of Fractal Images. Springer; 1 edition (July 19, 1988), page 199
  6. distance rendering for fractals by ińigo quilez
  7. fractalforums : mandelbrot-distance-estimation-problem
  8. Distance Estimator by Robert P. Munafo
  9. math.stackexchange question: how-to-draw-a-mandelbrot-set-with-the-connecting-filaments-visible
  10. Fractal forum : How are B&W images from "Beauty of Fractals" created?
  11. Distance Estimated 3D Fractals (V): The Mandelbulb & Different DE Approximations by Mikael Hvidtfeldt Christensen
  12. distance rendering for fractals by ińigo quilez
  13. distance estimation by Claude Heiland-Allen
  14. distance rendering for fractals by ińigo quilez
  15. fractalforums gallery by Pauldelbrot
  16. B of F map 43 DEM by Duncan Champney
  17. Smily Kaleidoscope by Duncan Champney
  18. Interior and exterior distance bounds for the Mandelbrot by Albert Lobo Cusidó
  19. Interior and exterior distance bounds for the Mandelbrot by Albert Lobo Cusidó
  20. Interior coordinates in the Mandelbrot set by Claude
  21. Fractal forum : Coloring points inside the Mandelbrot set
  22. MandelbrotDE in processing by ttoinou
  23. fractalforums : classic-mandelbrot-with-distance-and-gradient-for-coloring